Sassounian: Israel Has One Good Reason for Recognizing the Genocide

Israel’s Parliament, the Knesset, held “an historic session” on June 12, during which “seven different political parties overwhelmingly endorsed recognition of the Armenian Genocide,” according to Dr. Israel Charny, the executive director of the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide in Jerusalem. He cautiously predicted that the Knesset would complete its legislative procedures leading to recognition of the Armenian Genocide.

Israel Charny

While acknowledging the genocide would be salutary, Israel should have done so long ago. In fact, the Jewish state should have been the first country to recognize the genocide, in view of the awesome legacy of the Holocaust, the Shoah. Who should empathize more with the victims of genocide than those who have suffered a similar fate themselves? As Knesset member Nino Abesadze pointed out during the hearing, “It is precisely because we have been a victim people that we do not dare fail to identify with another victim people.” Another influential Knesset member, Zeev Elkin, the chair of the Likud Caucus, stated, “We are one of the last nations in the world that has still not recognized the Armenian Genocide. It is our moral responsibility that we have still not met.”
During the June 12 hearing, Knesset Chairman Reuven Rivlin spoke “firmly and inspiringly” with “profound feeling of both a Jewish and an Israeli imperative to extend a long overdue recognition,” Charny reported. Rivlin announced that there was no need for a new vote to recognize the Armenian Genocide since the Knesset had already voted unanimously for its recognition last year. Charny explained that unlike the U.S. Congress, Knesset resolutions first go to the Plenary Session before being considered by one of its committees. The next step for the genocide resolution is the Education Committee, after which it will be sent back to the Knesset for a final vote. Only then can it be said that the Knesset has officially recognized the Armenian Genocide.
One of the unexpected developments at the June 12 hearing was a statement by Minister of Environmental Affairs Gilad Erdan, who announced that he was speaking officially on behalf of the government. He stated unambiguously that Israel had decided to recognize the Armenian Genocide. Furthermore, Erdan claimed that “the State of Israel has never denied it; on the contrary, we deplore the [Armenian] genocide.” This was a surprising statement, since it is well known that, under Turkish pressure, Israel has persistently opposed recognition of the genocide. Nevertheless, in defiance of Israeli state denialism, on April 24, 2000, Minister of Justice Yossi Beilin and Minister of Education Yossi Sarid acknowledged the Armenian Genocide, prompting the government to repudiate their statements. Beilin had also recognized the genocide in 1994, while serving as deputy foreign minister.
The fact that serious discussions on the Armenian Genocide are now taking place at a time of deteriorating relations between Turkey and Israel raises troubling questions about the motives of the Israeli government. It would be morally repugnant to see the mass murder of a nation being exploited for crass political calculations. Yet, one has to realize that international relations are rarely based on moral principles. Were it not for economic and political considerations, the whole world would have long ago recognized the Armenian Genocide.
While critics may be displeased that Israel is considering recognition of the genocide at a time of discord with Turkey, the greater wrong, in my view, was not doing the right thing for all these years. Even now, despite efforts to rectify the past and uphold the truth, some Israeli officials are concerned that raising the Armenian Genocide issue would further exacerbate relations with Turkey. Knesset member Arieh Eldad dismissed such objections by pointing out the illogical stance of the naysayers: “A few years ago, people said we couldn’t talk about it because of our good relations with Turkey. Now people say we can’t talk about it because of our bad relations with Turkey.”
Eldad added that when people are reluctant to address moral and ethical issues there is always a claim that the timing of such a discussion is wrong.
There is, however, one red line that no Armenian should cross: Israeli officials have sought to obtain political concessions from Armenia and Armenians in return for genocide recognition. Such demands should be rejected outright since Armenians do not owe anything to Israel for recognizing the genocide—a universally acknowledged historical fact. Israel should recognize the Armenian Genocide simply because it is the right thing to do, reflecting the sentiments of all righteous Jews worldwide.

Alchemy near the Chasm of Death: Visiting a Mass Grave of the Armenian Genocide

“They brought the Armenians here. Thousands of them. They stripped them of their belongings and threw them into the chasm,” explains a Kurdish villager who had spotted us while driving by.

“They brought the Armenians here. Thousands of them. They stripped them of their belongings and threw them into the chasm.” Chasm appears as dark opening at the center. (Photo by Nanore Barsoumian)

We are standing at the mouth of a deep, eerie cleft—bottomless, according to the locals—called Dudan by Armenians and Kurds for centuries (also known as Yudan Dere).
“How do you know the Armenians were killed here?” I ask.
It’s not that I’m skeptical. We know from various survivor and perpetrator accounts that the 10,000 Armenians of Chunkush (Çüngüş, a district of the province of Diyarbakir) were led here by gendarmes and armed chetes in 1915, brutally murdered, and hurled into the chasm.
“There was a woman in our village. She lived to be 104,” he replies. “She saw it all.”
He pauses. “Everybody knows.”
We had already realized that everybody knew. In Chunkush, one of the locals, a teenager, had given us directions to Dudan where, he said, the entire population of the almost exclusively Armenian village had perished.
As we were driving in that direction, we asked a man where Dudan is. He jumped into our van and led us there. When we got to Dudan, our driver, a Kurd from Diyarbakir, asked him, “What happened here?”
“Nothing,” the man murmured.
“They say something happened to the Armenians here,” the driver insisted.

Dudan is “a famous cavern [that] drops vertically downward several hundred feet. The entire population of the town [of Chunkush] were said to have been driven to their death in this cavern.” (Photo by Khatchig Mouradian)

At that point, the man became visibly angry. “I do not know,” he said, and stormed out of the van.
***
The murder of the Armenians of Chunkush constitutes one of the largest, most brutal in situ massacres of the Armenian Genocide. The Armenians from Chunkush were marched to Dudan—only two hours away by foot—and massacred on the spot. Historian Raymond Kevorkian writes:
“The males were dealt with first, in accordance with a classic procedure: tied together in small groups of fewer than 10, they were handed over to butchers who bayoneted them or killed them with axes and then threw the bodies into the chasm. The method used on the women was quite similar, except that they were first systematically stripped and searched and then had their throats cut, after which their corpses were also thrown into the chasm. Some of them preferred to leap into the abyss themselves, dragging their children with them; thus they cheated their murderers of part of their booty.”¹
In his memoir, Rev. Henry H. Riggs, an American missionary who served in Kharpert (Harput), describes Dudan as “a famous cavern [that] drops vertically downward several hundred feet.” He adds, “the entire population of the town [of Chunkush] were said to have been driven to their death in this cavern.”²
Almost no one survived. The massacre was so comprehensive that “not a single Armenian from Chunkush appeared on the bloody deportation routes…in Aleppo, Der Zor, Damascus, or any part of Arabia,” writes Karnig Kevorkian in his 600-page book on Chunkush.³

At that point, the man became visibly angry. “I do not know,” he said, and stormed out of the van. (Photo by Nanore Barsoumian)

***
“This place smells of death,” says George, one of my co-travelers. “I can’t stay here any longer.” He walks towards the van, leaving me and my colleague, Nanore, behind.
I myself have never felt any closer to what can best be described as a doorway to hell. We take pictures, record a video of the site, and start surveying the area—just in case.
“The only way to get to the bottom of this is to get to the bottom of this,” I tell Nanore, and silently congratulate myself for figuring out a lame way to momentarily lighten the mood.
As we walk back, the Kurdish villager approaches me and, hesitantly, mutters: “Can I ask you something?”
“Sure!” I say, as I continue walking.
“My grandfather found a lot of items. They belonged to Armenians…”
Now he has my attention. “Go on!”
“Well, people in my village say these items were all made of gold, but that when they were found, they turned into copper.”
I am confused. “Really?”
“Yes, yes. That’s what they say. They also say that if someone can read the Armenian inscriptions on them, they will turn back to gold.”
I am dumbfounded. But I ask him to continue.
“So I was wondering,” he says, “whether you’d be willing to read them for me.”
Of all the possible responses pushing each other in my mind, trying to come out in words, I opt for the most diplomatic one. “I doubt that I have such powers, but bring them!”

After a few minutes, we see a man, a woman, and several kids with loads of tools and copper and silver trays and utensils walking in our direction… (Photo by Nanore Barsoumian)

The Kurdish villager takes out his cell phone and makes a call. He then asks us to get back into the van and follow him. I tell my co-travelers about our conversation.
“I really want to see what this guy has,” I say. “We’ll be careful.”
We hop into the van and follow his car. A few minutes later, he pulls up near a field. We get off, still suspicious, and wait for him to make another phone call.
After a few minutes, we see a man, a woman, and several kids with loads of utensils and copper and silver trays walking in our direction…

TURKEY MUST ADMITT THEY COMMITTED GENOCIDE AGAINST THE ARMENIANS

Rivlin: Remembering Armenian genocide not attack on Turkey

By GIL HOFFMAN, JPOST.COM STAFF

06/12/2012 18:35

Knesset discusses murder of more than a million Armenians at the hands of the Turks over a hundred years ago; Meretz leader Gal-On accuses gov't of using tragedy to attack Turkey, calls for 'Marmara' apology.

Photo: Courtesy: Knesset Channel

Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin said Tuesday that Israel has an obligation to remember the murder of more than a million Armenians at the hands of the Turks more than a hundred years ago, but warned that the issue should not be turned into an attack on the Turkish government of today. The Knesset speaker made the comments at a Knesset discussion of the Armenian genocide.
Speaking a day before State Comptroller Micha Lindenstrauss was scheduled to release a report on Israel’s interception of Turkish ships bound for the Gaza Strip which led to a diplomatic crisis between the countries, Rivlin insisted that the discussion of the Armenian genocide was not politically motivated.
"We have an ethical obligation to remember that a million Armenians were killed. It is forbidden to make the issue political. Our charges are not pointed at the Turkish regime today. We must make our voices heard when other nations are targeted for destruction," Rivlin stated.
"Those who drafted the Final Solution for the Jews figured the world would be silent as they were when the Armenians were murdered. The Knesset cannot ignore this episode that is factual. We cannot forgive nations who ignore our disaster and we cannot ignore the disasters of others," the Knesset speaker added.
Meretz chairwoman Zehava Gal-On, who initiated the Knesset discussion, accused the government of Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu of using the Armenian tragedy to attack Turkey.
Gal-On stated the government should "finally recognize" the episode as a genocide and restore relations with Turkey by agreeing to apologize for the deaths of nine Turkish pro-Palestinian activists at the hands of IDF commandos during the May 2010 raid of the Mavi Marmara vessel, which was part of a flotilla attempting to break the blockade of the Gaza Strip.
"The Armenian genocide is not an opportunity for public diplomacy," Gal-On told the Knesset plenum, adding that "Israel is strong enough to apologize for the killing of Turkish citizens without it harming Israel's honor or its security. We don't need to choose between recognizing genocide and relations with Turkey. We can have both."
The Meretz leader stated that "the Jewish people who have experienced the worst Holocaust have an obligation to show sensitivity to the disasters of others."
National Union MK Arieh Eldad called on Turkey to recognize its responsibility for its "historical crime," which he said included children being "put into cellars and gassed." Eldad quoted Adolf Hitler as having said "who remembers what happened to the Armenians," when he was asked what the world would say about his Final Solution against the Jews.
Kadima MK Robert Tibayev was the only lawmaker to speak against Israel recognizing the Armenian genocide, saying that Israel should not interfere in the issue, but rather let historians, or an international body decide if there was a genocide.
Balad MK Saed Nafaa, a Christian, took the opportunity to accuse current Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan of being hypocritical by complaining about the atrocities being committed by Syrian President Bashar Assad against his people while he himself has killed dozens of Kurds.
http://www.jpost.com/DiplomacyAndPolitics/Article.aspx?id=273608
###

MKs: 'We must recognize Armenian tragedy'

Knesset debates whether to recognize mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I as genocide
Moran Azulay

Published:  06.12.12, 18:31 / Israel News

The Knesset held a special session Tuesday on the mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I. "We must not politicize this matter," said Knesset Speaker Rivlin, adding that in spite of the sensitivity of the issue, there is no intention to blame Turkey or the current Turkish government.
MK Zahava Gal-On, chairwoman of the Meretz faction, who initiated the discussion, said that in recent years "the Armenian genocide has been swept under the rug" due to foreign relations concerns.

"Remembering and recognizing this genocide is our moral obligation. However, the timing of the discussion is problematic, when it is used for political bashing."
Recognition of the Armenian genocide by Israel would enrage Turkey and further strain the already tense ties between the two countries.
For years, Israel has refrained from commenting on the matter for fear of angering Turkey, which until recently was its closest ally in the Muslim world. But as ties have frayed under the Islamic-oriented rule of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Israel appears to be changing course.

Armenian Death March

The Armenian genocide remembrance day is marked every year on April 24. The mass murders by the Ottoman Turks were carefully planned and executed during and after World War I. Hundreds of thousands were sent to labor camps.
Finally, the Ottoman Turks chased the remaining Armenians from their villages to Syria in a death march. Women, children and elderly people marched for weeks without food or water, hunted down by soldiers and criminals. During the marches thousands were perished, murdered, raped and even burnt alive. In villages near the Black Sea, the Turks put the Armenians on boats and drowned them.
Reports on the atrocities reached Europe and the US as early as 1915, which immediately condemned the acts and blamed the Ottoman regime for "crimes against humanity."

The Ottoman massacre of the Armenians was the first genocide of the 20th century, and remains the center of political debate. The Turks continue to deny the genocide, claiming that the Armenians were only transferred, and that deaths only occurred during the fighting between the Armenians and the Kurds.
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4241591,00.html
###

Reuven Rivlin: “As a country struggling in the international arena with Holocaust denial, we cannot deny the tragedy of another people”

As it was informed yesterday Israeli Knesset is going to have a debate on the recognition of Armenian Genocide.
As timesofisrael.com web-site writes as Israeli relations with Turkey continue to deteriorate, on Tuesday the Knesset marked the Armenian genocide with a special session to debate recognition of the genocide.
“The Israeli parliament has in the past refrained from public debates on the subject for fear of alienating the Turkish government, one of the Jewish state’s few allies in a hostile Middle East.
However, the timing of the discussion about the Armenian genocide, perpetrated by the Ottomans about a century ago, coincides with the release of the state comptroller’s report about the 2010 raid on the Mavi Marmara, a Turkish ship attempting to break the blockade of the Gaza Strip, in which the IDF killed nine Turkish nationals, as well as the Turkish decision to indict senior IDF officials in absentia over the incident.
Knesset Speaker Reuven Rivlin said that the discussion of the genocide, promoted by MK Zahava Gal-On (Meretz), was not connected to the current strained relations between Israel and Turkey”, the source writes.
Rivlin also told Globes: “As Jews, and as human beings, we cannot ignore this issue and we must not turn away from our commitment to morality… As [a country] struggling in the international arena with Holocaust denial, we cannot deny the tragedy of another people.”
In December 2011, the Knesset Education Committee discussed the Armenian genocide for the first time. Gal-On, who also initiated that discussion, said then: “For years, Israel always took into account its relations with Turkey. That is the central issue in terms of recognition of the murder of the Armenian people, which has yet to take place in Israel’s Knesset,” Haaretz.com wrote.
Photo from timesofisrael.com
http://times.am/?l=0&p=8401
###

With eye on Turkey, Israel debates Armenia deaths

June 12, 2012

JERUSALEM—The Israeli parliament has begun a debate over whether to recognize the mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I as genocide.

Such a move would enrage Turkey and further strain the already tense ties between the two countries.

For years, Israel has refrained from commenting on the matter for fear of angering Turkey, which until recently was its closest ally in the Muslim world. But as ties have frayed under the Islamic-oriented rule of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Israel appears to be changing course.

Parliament speaker Reuven Rivlin denied that Tuesday's debate was related to deteriorating ties with Turkey. In a radio interview, he said there is no intent to provoke, only to remember.

It was unclear if there would be a vote Tuesday.
http://www.boston.com/news/world/middleeast/articles/2012/06/12/with_eye_on_turkey_israel_debates_armenia_deaths/
###

Israel's Knesset Discusses Armenian Genocide in Move Set to Anger Turkey

Israeli parliament opens debate over recognition of mass killing by Ottoman Turks during First World War.

By Gianluca Mezzofiore
June 12, 2012 5:08 PM GMT

The Israeli parliament, the Knesset, has begun a controversial debate about recognising the massacre of more than one and a half million Armenians by Ottoman Turks during the First World World War as genocide.

• 

Enlarge

(Photo: Wikipedia)
Israeli MPs discuss killings of one and a half million Armenians by Turkey during First World War

Following Turkey's decision to try senior Israeli officials in court for their part in a Israel Defence Forces raid on the Gaza-bound ship Mavi Marmara in 2009, Israel's move is likely to enrage Turkey and cause further tension in diplomatic relations between the two countries.
For years, the Knesset has avoided the subject in order not to upset Turkey.
Since diplomatic relations between Israel and Turkey have deteriorated under the moderate-Islamist rule of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, determination has grown to discuss the mass killings of Armenians by Turkey during the Ottoman Empire.
Knesset speaker Reuven Rivlin denied that the debate was set to provoke Turkey.

Fighting Holocaust denial
"As Jews, and as human beings, we cannot ignore this issue and we must not turn away from our commitment to morality," Rivlin said. "As [a country] struggling in the international arena with Holocaust denial, we cannot deny the tragedy of another people."
In December 2011, the Knesset Education Committee discussed the genocide for the first time.
"For years, Israel always took into account its relations with Turkey. That is the central issue in terms of recognition of the murder of the Armenian people, which has yet to take place in Israel's Knesset," said Meretz Party chair Zahava Gal-On, who is initiating the debate
Richard Giragosian, director of the Regional Studies Centre, said Israeli authorities want to use recognition of the genocide as an issue with which to "punish" Turkey. He noted that the move could negatively affect its international recognition campaign and possibly hamper efforts to get Turkey to acknowledge the genocide.
To report problems or to leave feedback about this article, e-mail: g.mezzofiore@ibtimes.co.uk
To contact the editor, e-mail: editor@ibtimes.co.uk

http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/articles/351327/20120612/israel-knesset-armenian-genocide.htm#ixzz1xb2ameKm

###

Israeli MP: no new Genocide-related issues raised at Knesset discussion

June 12, 2012 - 19:09 AMT

PanARMENIAN.Net - A public discussion about the Genocide of the Armenian people is ongoing at Israeli Knesset.
As Israeli MP and public figure Ze'ev Elkin told a PanARMENIAN.Net reporter, “nothing new has been said at the discussion.” As the politician said, the issue has already been submitted to Knesset’s Education and Culture Committee for consideration. “The discussion was purely ceremonial. No new Genocide-related issues were raised, the sitting being a plenary one,” he noted.
The public discussion was initiated at the request of MK Zahava Gal-On (Meretz) and supported by Knesset chairperson Reuven Rivlin.
http://www.panarmenian.net/eng/news/111504/

ARMENIAN FESTIVAL-JUNE 2 AND 3--WATERVLIET NY--ST PETER ARMENIAN CHURCH

2012 ARMENIAN FESTIVAL

Posted on May 2, 2012 by Latest News

Join us for always-delicious Armenian food and pastries ~ Armenian music and dancing ~ Exciting rides and activities for children ~ MEGA BUCKS RAFFLE along with daily 50/50 raffles ~ Saturday Night Tavloo (Backgammon) Tournament ~ Sunday afternoon dance lesson ~ Cooking demonstrations both days ~ Giftshop & Bookstore and vendors ~ and so much more . . .

SATURDAY, JUNE 2 ~ 12:00 noon to 7:00pm
SUNDAY, JUNE 3 ~ 12:00 noon to 5:00pm

Sponsorship opportunities also available.  Contact the church office for more information.

FESTIVAL MENU:

DINNERS

Kebab Medley Dinner $16
Includes one lamb shish kebab, one chicken shish kebab, one losh kebab, rice pilaf, tossed salad and pita bread. Garlic & lemon sauce available ~ great on the chicken!

Lamb Kebab Dinner $14
Includes one lamb shish kebab, one losh kebab, rice pilaf, tossed salad and pita bread.

Chicken Kebab Dinner $12
Includes two chicken kebabs, rice pilaf, tossed salad and pita bread. Garlic & lemon sauce available.

SANDWICHES & COMBO MEALS

Losh Kebab Sandwich $8 - One Losh Kebab on pita bread served with rice pilaf.
Lamb Kebab Sandwich $8 - Lamb Kebab meat on pita bread served w/rice pilaf.
Chicken Kebab Sandwich $7 - Chicken Kebab meat on pita bread served w/rice pilaf.
Lahmejune Meal $8 - Two lahmejune served w/tossed salad.
Kid’s Meal $5 - One hot dog served with rice pilaf.

ALA CARTE
Lahmejune $3 each (warmed) or $18 dozen (frozen)  - A traditional meat “pie” made on a flat bread with ground lamb, finely chopped vegetables and spices.
Rice Pilaf $6 serves 4+ - Traditional pilaf made with browned fine egg noodles, white rice, butter & chicken stock.
Fasoulia $3 serving - Stewed green beans with tomato, onion & garlic.
Tossed Salad $3 serving - Fresh garden salad with Italian dressing.
Cheese Beoreg $3 serving - Flaky, baked, cheese-filled phyllo dough.
Yalanchi $5/6pcs - Grape leaves stuffed with seasoned  onions & rice.
Hummus $6 serving - Dip made from pureed chic peas & sesame paste served with pita bread.
Babaganoush $6 serving - Dip made from pureed eggplant & sesame paste served with pita bread.

DESSERTS
A variety of homemade Armenian pastries will all be sold ala carte in the Bakery Area.  Some of the scrumptious desserts you will find include, but not limited to, the following:

Boorma - A delicious, light dessert made of phyllo dough filled with a syrup and nut mixture, and rolled into a finger-sized cylinder.
Kadayif - Made of shredded (‘bird’s nest”) dough filled with nuts and syrup.
Paklava - A flaky, layered dessert filled with nuts and syrup.
Cheoreg - A sweet roll made into individual spirals.
Paklava Sundae - Paklava pastry pieces over vanilla ice cream topped with optional chocolate or caramel sauce and whipped cream.
Also Available - Brownies, cookies and other assorted desserts.

BEVERAGES
Coffee will be served at the Bakery Area.  Beer, wine, bo-ttled water and soft drinks will be served at the Beverage Wagon.  Specialty Armenian beer and Armenian coffee will also be available.

RAFFLES & SPONSORSHIP:

Mega Bucks Raffle:  $25 per ticket with only 300 tickets available.  Three Cash Prizes:  $1,000   $500   $250.  Winners announced at Festival at 4:00 p.m. on Sunday, June 3.

Daily 50/50 Raffles: $5 per chance.  A winner will be drawn at the end of each Festival day.

Ticket holders need not be present to win.   Tickets may be purchased at the Festival or in advance by contacting the church office.  NYS ID #GC  01-103-099-09504

Festival Sponsorship Program: Sponsorship in the 2012 Festival will provide a means of publicity for your business or company.  As a means of support, individuals may also become Festival Sponsors.  Click here for a Sponsorship Form with full details.  Contact the church office by Tuesday, May 29, to be included in the Sponsorship program booklet.

SCHEDULE OF ACTIVITIES:

Saturday, June 2
12:00pm Parev! Festival Begins!
  2:00pm Cooking Demo: Pilaf
  3:00pm Cooking Demo: Pakalava
  4:00pm Cooking Demo: Eetch
  2:30pm Tavloo (Backgammon) Tournament begins: Registration Fee $15
  6:00pm 50/50 Raffle Drawing
  7:00pm Day 1 comes to a close!  Join us again on Sunday.

Sunday, June 3
12:00pm Day 2 Begins!
  1:30pm Tour of Church Sanctuary
  2:30pm Armenian Line Dance instruction
  3:30pm Cooking Demo: Simit
  4:00pm 50/50 Raffle Drawing & Mega Bucks Raffle Drawing
  5:00pm Festival ends!  Hope to see you next year!

OTHER ACTIVITIES: 10-n-1 Bounce House for the children; Bead-making activity, Dunk Tank, and more . . .

BOOKSTORE & GIFTSHOP
A wide variety of gift items will be available for purchase through our St. Peter Church Bookstore & Giftshop as well as from the many vendors participating in the 2012 Armenian Festival.   Among the new items available this year is a variety of Armenian T-shirts for adults, children and infants.  Click here to see a display of styles.