ITS Treasurer Edward Erickson: ‘It’s probably not genocide.’
WASHINGTON—Institute of Turkish Studies (ITS) Treasurer Edward
Erickson responded angrily on Feb. 5 to Armenian National Committee of
America (ANCA) questions about his position on the Armenian Genocide and
his organization’s ties to the Turkish government, threatening to have
ANCA Government Affairs Director Kate Nahapetian removed from his
lecture at Georgetown University.
“Can we get her out of here?” was Dr. Erickson’s response to
Nahapetian’s inquiry about whether he believed the murder of 1.5 million
Armenians constituted genocide. “This is not Turkey,” retorted
Nahapetian, noting that those holding positions not shared by the
lecturer cannot simply be silenced in the U.S.
The ITS had arranged for Erickson to lecture at the Georgetown
University Center for Contemporary Arab Studies Boardroom on his latest
book. Referencing Erickson’s opening assertion that history has an
agenda, that “resources drive policy” and “resources determine policy,”
ANCA Executive Director Aram Hamparian asked Erickson to clarify the
Institute of Turkish Studies’ ties to the Turkish government and its
policy of genocide denial. Dr. Erickson acknowledged that the ITS was
founded by a grant by the Turkish government, but claimed that “the ITS
has no strings attached, is not a puppet or an organ of the Turkish
government. It operates as a separate entity. It makes its own decisions
and its agenda has nothing to do with anything Armenian or the denial
of the genocide.”
Nahapetian challenged that assertion, reminding Erickson and
attendees that former ITS Chairman Donald Quataert felt compelled to
relinquish his position with the organization following a meeting with
then-Turkish Ambassador to the U.S. Nabi Sensoy, precipitated by an
article Quataert had written acknowledging the genocide.
In a 2008 “Inside Higher Ed” article, Quataert told reporter Scott
Jaschik that the ambassador “made it clear that if I did not separate
myself as chairman of the board, that funding for the institute would be
withdrawn by the Turkish government and the institute would be
destroyed.” Jaschik’s complete article on the topic, titled “Is Turkey
Muzzling U.S. Scholars?”, is available here.
ITS’s ties with the Turkish government were explored extensively in
the spring 1995 “Holocaust and Genocide Studies” Journal article titled,
“Professional Ethics and the Denial of Armenian Genocide,” by Dr. Roger
W. Smith, Dr. Eric Markusen, and Dr. Robert Jay Lifton, the full text
of which is available here.
Voice of America reporter Arsen Kharatyan and other attendees,
including Lee Jundanian and Dikran Dourian, asked other questions and
expressed their concerns about Erickson’s flawed scholarship and his
ties to Turkey’s international campaign of genocide denial. In what was
perhaps the most puzzling moment of the talk, when questioned a second
time on his position regarding the Armenian Genocide, this time by
Kharatyan, Erickson replied, “There are days I wake up and I think,
‘It’s probably genocide.’ There are days I wake up and I think ‘probably
not.’”
Following the lecture, Hamparian commented, “We saw today yet another
angry attempt by an Ankara-funded organization, this time the Institute
of Turkish Studies, to enforce—right here in America—Turkey’s shameful
gag-rule on the Armenian Genocide.”
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment